2020 Commercial 088 DxO


Valentine’s Guest House.

For more than a century, since 1910, the Valentines have accommodated transient guests at the family home on Commercial Street, qualifying for some kind of record in hospitality. The Valentines’ story is also woven through that of the fishery, and — like so many families tied to the sea — they have known their share of great sorrow.

In January 1941, Antone Francis Valentine (also known as Anthony), then around 60 years old, lost his life when the 90-foot trawler Mary E. O’Hara sank in Boston Harbor after hitting an anchored barge. She was returning from Georges Bank laden with 50,000 pounds of fish and most of the 23 crew members were asleep. “Suddenly, came the grinding noise of a collision,” The Advocate reported. “Men rushed to the deck, yelling to their companions to awake and follow. Under weight of the fish and the heavy coating of ice, the O’Hara settled swiftly. In vain the men struggled with the frozen dories.” The five who survived did so at the top of the two masts, to which they were frozen by the time rescuers arrived. Only four feet of the masts were above water.

Antone’s father, Manuel Valentine, and his brother Manuel Jr. had perished together 41 years earlier on the Grand Banks aboard the schooner Cora McKay. His son, Antone George Valentine (1928-2006), usually known as George, followed him into the fishery — at first. George was working for Atlantic Coast Fisheries in 1949, when he married Helen Gertrude Silva, a daughter of Frank Silva. In the ’50s, Valentine fished aboard F/V Liberty Belle and then, in 1955, purchased F/V New England, a 55-foot dragger, from Joseph Martin. He also owned the lobster boat Valente.

Helen Valentine is a grand materfamilias, indeed, continuing to run the guest house well into her 80s. Two of her children, Joy (Valentine) Long and Joady (Valentine) Brown, still live in town. And Mrs. Valentine has greatly enriched the Provincetown History Preservation Project by lending dozens and dozens of vintage photographs and post cards.

¶ Adapted from Building Provincetown (2015).

For further reading online

Valentine’s Guest House Facebook page.

For further viewing online

Helen Valentine Collection, No. 1. Provincetown History Preservation Project (Standalone documents), Page 4994.

Helen Valentine Collection, No. 2. Provincetown History Preservation Project (Standalone documents), Page 4995.

Helen Valentine Collection, No. 3. Provincetown History Preservation Project (Standalone documents), Page 4996.

Helen Valentine Collection, No. 4. Provincetown History Preservation Project (Standalone documents), Page 4997.

Helen Valentine Collection, No. 5. Provincetown History Preservation Project (Standalone documents), Page 4998.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.