2020 Commercial 064 House


A classic full Cape — long the home of Roslyn Garfield (1921-2012) and Phyllis Temple (1928-2008) — this house at 64 Commercial Street dates from the early 19th century, meaning that it originally faced the water, long before there was a Commercial Street. But it did so at a different location: across from the Red Inn. It was moved to this site in 1840. At the turn of the 20th century, when it was denominated 51 Commercial, under the old street numbering system, this was the property of Ella A. Small. In the 1930s, Ella A. (Smith) Sibley offered rooms to let here. In 1945, her heirs sold 64 Commercial Street to Irving and Rachel Ashley Sametz of Westport, Conn., operators of the Ashley Shop at 445 Commercial Street. They, in turn, sold the property to Garfield in 1956.

Garfield was credited as having been in the nucleus of the “first wave” of lesbian wash-ashores in the 1940s and ’50s by Karen Christel Krahulik in Provincetown: From Pilgrim Landing to Gay Resort (2005). “Roslyn Garfield arrived as a schoolteacher, a respected and likely occupation for women at the time,” Krahulik wrote. She taught at Nauset High School and was a partner with Judith Tobey in a shop at 220 Commercial Street that was first called the Etcetera Shop and then Shirts Etcetera. In the 1960s, Garfield was also involved with the Provincetown Collegium Musicum, an annual gathering of music students who studied and performed on Baroque and Renaissance instruments like the harpsichord, lute, and viol.

At the same time, Krahulik noted, “she branched out into male-dominated fields, embarking first on a career in real estate before becoming a prominent attorney as well as the town moderator.” The town moderator, elected every three years, presides over Town Meeting; in essence, the annual legislative session in which the voters consider all operating and capital budgetary measures. The moderator also appoints members of the finance committee and fills vacancies on other bodies if appointing authorities fail to act. Garfield served six terms, or 18 years, from 1985 to 2003. Unopposed in 1997, she received 81 percent of the vote. Unopposed again in 2000, she received 77 percent of the vote; not a bad approval rating for a 15-year incumbent. (And in Provincetown!)

When the Town Meeting of 2007 needed a temporary moderator, voters turned again to … you-know-who. “Garfield received a thunderous ovation when she took the gavel and presided over the four-hour-plus meeting,” The Cape Codder reported. During Roslyn Garfield Week in 2010, Jay Critchley of the Provincetown Community Compact presented her with a sand-encrusted gavel, recalling her role in successfully defending his first significant art installation, Just Visiting for the Weekend. At 83, Garfield was appointed Provincetown’s representative to the Cape Cod Commission, the regional planning and regulatory authority. She served until 2009.

Garfield used 64 Commercial Street not only as home but as an antiques and crafts business in the 1950s, and then for her real estate business. Conrad Malicoat (1936-2014), who turned fireplaces into artworks, executed an utterly delightful brick chimney with a relief of a breaching whale. He also created the Gaudí-esque millwork in the kitchen. Another significant piece of art built right into the house is a sculptural column in wood by the artist Joan Wye (1926-2006). Wye’s most prominent public work in town was the colorful mast — a kind of abstract totem pole — that used to stand in front of the Provincetown Art House. She playfully signed her works “JY.”

For a view of the Malicoat chimney, please see 64 Commercial Street.

Garfield’s life was deeply intertwined with that of Phyllis Temple, her partner for 40 years, and the principal real estate broker for Roslyn Garfield Associates for 36 years. “She was one of the first volunteers for the Provincetown AIDS Support Group,” The Banner said in her obituary.

She and Roslyn served many hours as the auction recorders for the Fine Arts Work Center and the AIDS Support Group auctions. She was a volunteer at both the Provincetown Heritage Museum and the Provincetown Art Association and Museum, and she and Roslyn for many years hosted the annual potluck event for the Provincetown Conservation Trust. In 2001 she received the Leadership Award from the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. From beach picnics to the most elegant restaurants in Paris, Phyllis never failed to have a grand time. And she was always up for an adventure. There are those who remember her sinking into a quaking bog while on a Provincetown Center for Coastal Studies walk and never missing a beat. Not to mention her delight at actually touching the skin of an orca in Provincetown Harbor.

The house was bequeathed by Garfield to the performer and activist Kate Clinton and her partner, Urvashi Vaid, a prominent human rights advocate, who moved here from 3A Carnes Lane, where more about them will be found.

¶ Last updated on 3 July 2018.

Jo Nol wrote on 5 February 2015: Very nice to have stumbled onto this page. I had the honor of meeting and spending time with both Roz and Phyllis. It was wonderful to get to know them and to see them in action as vital movers and shakers in their community.

One thought on “64 Commercial Street

  1. Roz, Phyllis, and my grandparents, Eileen and Carl Kolodin, were good friends. I remember many happy hours spent with them at 61 Commercial Street (Alice and Hazel’s main house). Back in the ’50s and ’60s Roz was known as “Danny.” Eventually, it became impolite to call her anything other than Roslyn. One afternoon, Roz brought Norman Mailer over with her to share cocktails with my grandparents. I was only about 14 and didn’t realize who was sitting in our living room! So many wonderful memories.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.